I am always amazed at the improvisation that the great singers introduce into their vocal renditions every time they get to expound on the same raag, cheez, or ghazal. They take the liberty -and at will dwell much longer on a few words, a line or even introduce lines/pieces of verse written by someone else. This happens frequently with the great ghazal singers, Ghulam Ali does it more often than Mehdi Hassan sahab or Jagjit Singh ji, to name a few exponents of the same genre. The great vocalists take liberty with the presentation depending on their mood at the moment and the same raag by the same vocalist creates a different level of satiation and impact at different times.
Let’s listen in to a ghazal by Ghulam Ali. I bumped into it early this morning while looking for something else and will use it to illustrate my point. The straightforward rendition in the studio version is so good, direct, short and sweet. https://youtu.be/lusxUXxSQJI?si=fFQJ1APqbSeFFafg
मैं नज़र से पी रहा हूँ ये समाँ बदल न जाए
अनवर मिर्जापुरी
मैं नज़र से पी रहा हूँ ये समाँ बदल न जाए
न झुकाओ तुम निगाहें कहीं रात ढल न जाए
मेरे अश्क भी हैं इस में ये शराब उबल न जाए
मेरा जाम छूने वाले तेरा हाथ जल न जाए
अभी रात कुछ है बाक़ी न उठा नक़ाब साक़ी
तेरा रिंद गिरते गिरते कहीं फिर सँभल न जाए
मेरी ज़िंदगी के मालिक मेरे दिल पे हाथ रखना
तेरे आने की ख़ुशी में मेरा दम निकल न जाए
मुझे फूँकने से पहले मेरा दिल निकाल लेना
ये किसी की है अमानत मेरे साथ जल न जाए
किसी खौफ़ से नशेमन मैं बना सका न ‘अनवर’,
ये निगाहें अहल-ए-गुलशन कहीं फिर बदल न जाये
A longer rendition from a live concert is more relaxed and sounds different with the flavour of Darbari raag. Ghulam Ali liberally introduces various ash’aar by others too. You’ll get the deja vu like feeling when you hear them. But he introduces the maqta which is missing in the studio recording. https://youtu.be/A3zq26FjXlQ?si=n0TBgxL5JvgVhh89
It isn’t at all fair to compare two greats, but Ghulam Ali and Mehdi Hassan have entirely different effects on my mind. I love Ghulam Ali in the first half (or two thirds) of his career when he did some more honest, straightforward singing than in the latter part, when gimmicky vocal moves took over his unquestioned singing abilities, very sadly.
Just to round it off, check out the same ghazal in Tilang by Mehdi Hassan sahab. It sounds so very different due to his vocal style and timbre. https://youtu.be/FBuUYTzW4ug?si=8BZVLGnUwe8Lff8X
It changes the tone and creates an entirely different mood from the first notes of the harmonium at the very introduction. An amazing one, too. So very different, especially because he intersperses the ash’aar with lines in Punjabi by other poets.
Have a great day ahead, and hope you enjoyed the variations by the two leading exponents from the neighbourhood (infested by serpents of a particularly venomous variety that actually seek to ban all musical forms).
Stay healthy and happy. A drought looms large in my state and I pray to the supreme being to mitigate the suffering…